Repair or replace an appliance: compare the whole cost
A step-by-step comparison of repair cost, remaining life, warranty and running cost, with an invented worked example, for deciding whether to fix or replace a broken appliance.

When an appliance breaks, the repair quote tends to decide the matter on its own: it is either cheap enough to accept or shocking enough to reject. That skips most of what matters. The better comparison puts the repair and the replacement on the same footing, over the same period.
This guide sets out the checks to make and a simple way to compare, using invented figures. It does not say which choice is right for any household.
Check for a recall and a warranty first
Before paying for anything, rule out the free routes.
Search the Consumer Product Safety Commission’s recall list by product and hazard. If your model is recalled, CPSC says to stop using it and follow the remedy in the notice, which can be a refund, repair, replacement or instructions to make it safe, and to contact the company using the details given (CPSC recalls, checked November 18, 2026).
Then check warranties. The Federal Trade Commission suggests looking at the length of coverage, what is and is not covered (it says to assume anything not listed is not covered), what the company will do if the product fails, and the claims process, including whether you pay for labor or shipping. It also notes you may have to return a registration card first to qualify for warranty service, and that implied warranties may exist under state law unless the seller disclaims them (FTC warranties, checked November 18, 2026). Check also whether a credit card or a service plan you bought covers the item. The paperwork for that is covered in keeping household records.
Get the repair quote in a form you can compare
Ask for the diagnosis, the part, labor, any service-call charge, and how long the repair is guaranteed. Ask what else is likely to fail on a machine of that age. If the quote is large, a second opinion is reasonable. The approach in comparable quotes works for repair technicians too.
Appliances that burn gas, hold pressure or connect to household wiring or plumbing need a qualified technician to diagnose and repair. Do not attempt those repairs yourself on the strength of a video.

Put both options on the same yearly footing
A simple method is to convert each option into a cost per year of use: the money you spend now, plus the running cost over the years you expect to get, divided by those years. You are guessing at the years, so write your guess down and test it.
This is an invented example for a refrigerator. All numbers are assumptions, not typical values and not a quote.
- Repair: $300 now. The old unit is assumed to use 600 kWh a year and to last three more years.
- Replace: $900 now. The new unit is assumed to use 400 kWh a year and to last 12 years.
- Electricity is assumed at $0.15 per kWh, a teaching rate. Use your own rate from your bill (reading your electricity bill shows where).
| Repair | Replace | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | $300 | $900 |
| Annual electricity | 600 × $0.15 = $90 | 400 × $0.15 = $60 |
| Electricity over the period | $90 × 3 = $270 | $60 × 12 = $720 |
| Total over the period | $300 + $270 = $570 | $900 + $720 = $1,620 |
| Cost per year | $570 ÷ 3 = $190 | $1,620 ÷ 12 = $135 |
On these assumptions replacement costs less per year, even though it costs three times as much today. Change the assumptions and the answer can flip. If the repair bought six years instead of three, the repair works out at ($300 + $540) ÷ 6 = $140 per year, close to the replacement. The remaining-life guess matters far more than the electricity difference, which here is $30 a year ($90 minus $60).
Look at running cost with real data
ENERGY STAR lets you browse certified products by category and search by specification, and runs a rebate finder and a page on tax credits and rebates for efficient home upgrades by ZIP code (ENERGY STAR, checked November 18, 2026). Use these to find the energy use of a replacement and to see whether any incentive exists where you live. Incentives and their rules change, so confirm eligibility on the program page before counting on one. Do not assume a certified model is the cheapest or best fit for your household; it is a way to compare energy use.
For your current appliance, the nameplate or manual gives its rating. Real use depends on how you use it and on its age and condition, so a nameplate is a starting point.
Weigh what the arithmetic leaves out
A few factors do not fit in the table. Safety comes first: if the failure involves overheating, leaking gas or a recall, replacement or a professional’s judgment should lead. Reliability counts, because an old appliance that has just failed once may fail again. Fit counts, as a replacement may differ in size, hookups or venting. Timing counts too: a household without a working refrigerator or heater needs a decision quickly, which affects what is practical.
A replacement is also a cash event. If paying $900 at once would strain the household, the cheaper-per-year option may not be the workable one. For how to save toward replacements, compare financing and pay less, see Money Master.
Write the decision down
Record the quote, the model and serial number, your assumed years, your electricity rate and the result. When the next appliance fails you will have a method and a baseline, and your maintenance calendar can carry the expected-replacement dates, so repairs are not always emergencies.
Common questions
Is there a rule of thumb for when to replace? Some people use a fraction of the replacement cost, but those rules ignore age, running cost and warranty. The yearly-cost comparison above is a better test, and your own assumptions drive it.
Does a manufacturer warranty require using its own repair service? The FTC says a manufacturer cannot require specific parts or services to keep warranty coverage unless it provides them free or has an FTC waiver. Read your warranty’s terms for what it does cover.
Can the old appliance be recycled or hauled away? Ask the retailer or your local waste authority.
Sources checked November 18, 2026: CPSC recalls, FTC warranties, ENERGY STAR home page. All appliance figures are invented examples. General information, not financial or professional advice.