Time-of-use rates: compare your own usage under two tariffs

A clearly hypothetical comparison showing why usage timing, fixed charges and the same billing period matter.

An ordinary laundry area lit by late-afternoon daylight.

A lower electricity rate can still produce a higher bill if it applies at the wrong hours or comes with different fixed charges. A time-of-use plan adds another question to “how much did we use?”: when did we use it?

Use the same household usage record to understand two rate structures. This guide uses invented tariffs to show the mechanics. It is not a recommendation to switch to a named plan or a prediction of your savings.

Start with a bill you can reconcile

If kWh, usage charges and balances are still mixed together, begin with the electricity-bill guide. Then obtain the actual rate-plan documents and, where available, your provider’s interval-usage data.

PG&E describes time-of-use pricing as varying by the time of day, with lower prices in off-peak periods. It also states that some time-of-use plans have tiers: time bands and usage tiers can apply together, so check both in the actual tariff. That is a real provider’s explanation of the structure, not the source of the example prices below. PG&E: how rates work.

For a real comparison, identify the effective dates, time periods, seasons, weekends and holidays, any tiers, fixed charges and other applicable adjustments. “Off-peak” is a label in a particular tariff, not a universal clock time.

Compare one usage record under two invented tariffs

Assume a hypothetical billing period with 600 kWh of imported electricity. Of that, 180 kWh falls into the example’s peak periods and 420 kWh into off-peak periods.

Tariff A charges $0.24 per kWh at all times plus a $15 fixed charge. Tariff B charges $0.42 per peak kWh and $0.18 per off-peak kWh, plus a $20 fixed charge. These are invented US-dollar teaching figures, not current utility prices. No tax, solar export credit or other adjustment is included.

Calculation Tariff A Tariff B
Peak usage Included in 600 × $0.24 180 × $0.42 = $75.60
Off-peak usage Included in 600 × $0.24 420 × $0.18 = $75.60
Total usage charge $144.00 $151.20
Fixed charge $15.00 $20.00
Example total $159.00 $171.20

Although Tariff B has the lower off-peak rate, it costs $12.20 more for this invented usage pattern. Multiplying all 600 kWh by $0.18 would ignore both the peak usage and the fixed charge.

Separate the tariff from a possible change in routine

Now imagine that 60 kWh could genuinely move from peak to off-peak periods without changing total consumption. The revised record would be 120 peak kWh and 480 off-peak kWh.

Under Tariff B, the usage charge becomes $50.40 plus $86.40, or $136.80. Add its $20 fixed charge and the example total is $156.80. Tariff A remains $159 because its price does not depend on timing in this example.

Moving those 60 kWh reduces Tariff B’s example bill by $14.40, but makes it only $2.20 below Tariff A. Those are different comparisons. Neither number establishes an annual saving in a real household.

The assumption that 60 kWh can move is the part to investigate. Do not reschedule medical equipment, refrigeration or other essential use to fit a spreadsheet. Follow appliance instructions, household safety needs and any supervision requirements. An inconvenient or unsafe routine is not a sound plan.

A closed washing machine and an empty laundry basket in a quiet household utility area.

Check the calendar before scaling up

A real plan may change rates or periods by season, treat holidays differently, or calculate some charges per day. Compare the same dates and the same interval record under each eligible tariff. Check the time zone and interval definitions in the provider’s data, and make sure the rows add back to the bill’s usage.

One mild month does not represent heating, cooling and travel patterns across a whole year. If you cannot obtain suitable data, use the exercise to identify questions for the provider rather than describing it as a personal savings estimate.

For solar or a battery, imported kWh and exported kWh may be treated differently. This simple example has neither. Do not use it to price a solar system or model a battery that has purchase cost, losses and operating constraints.

Keep the result tied to the assumptions

Save the usage period, tariff versions, eligibility conditions and included charges beside the comparison. Ask the provider about anything that does not reconcile. If an official comparison tool is available, read what its estimate assumes rather than treating its headline as a guarantee.

For how a changing bill fits the household budget, Money Master covers choosing a budgeting method. Card Calculator handles the separate utility-payment card question. Your task here is to understand the rate structure and your usage record before making either decision.

Sources