Replacement cost or actual cash value: what your home policy pays after a loss

How replacement cost and actual cash value settlements differ, with an invented worked example, and the policy wording to find before you ever file a claim.

A cozy living room with a sofa, lamp and bookshelf.

Two insured households can suffer the same loss and receive very different checks. One reason is the settlement basis, the method the policy uses to value what was damaged. The two names you will meet most often are replacement cost and actual cash value, often shortened to ACV.

This guide explains the difference, walks through an invented example, and lists what to look for in your own policy. It is general information, not advice. The actual wording of your policy, and your state’s rules, decide what would be paid.

What the two terms mean

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) tells readers to check whether claims are paid at replacement cost, which it describes as the amount needed to rebuild or repair without deducting for depreciation. Actual cash value pays what it takes to repair or replace the damage after depreciation (NAIC, checked November 18, 2026).

Depreciation is a reduction for age and wear, so ACV is generally lower than replacement cost. In plain terms, replacement cost aims to cover repair or replacement without that reduction; ACV subtracts it.

An invented worked example

All figures below are hypothetical, chosen to show the arithmetic. They are not quotes, and real insurers apply their own depreciation schedules and wording.

Suppose a covered storm damages part of a roof and the repair costs $9,500 at today’s prices. The insurer applies depreciation of $4,000 because the roof is old. The policy has a $2,500 deductible. To keep it simple, assume the deductible is subtracted from the valuation.

Replacement cost basis Actual cash value basis
Cost to repair at current prices $9,500 $9,500
Depreciation deducted $0 $4,000
Valuation $9,500 $5,500
Deductible $2,500 $2,500
Payment $7,000 $3,000

Check: $9,500 minus $2,500 is $7,000. $9,500 minus $4,000 is $5,500, and $5,500 minus $2,500 is $3,000. Same loss, same deductible, a $4,000 difference in payment.

Roof repairs are only one illustration. Whether the deductible comes off before or after depreciation, and whether payment arrives in one amount or in stages, depends on the policy. Those are questions for the policy wording and the insurer, not something this example settles.

Where the basis appears in your policy

Look for the settlement or loss-settlement wording in the full policy, not only the summary page. NAIC says the declarations page identifies coverages, limits and endorsements, while exclusions, conditions and endorsements elsewhere in the policy shape what is paid. Anything that increases or adds coverage beyond the basic policy is in the endorsements, which NAIC says should be listed on the declarations page (NAIC, checked November 18, 2026).

A policy can value different parts differently. As a general point not drawn from NAIC, a policy can use a different basis for the building than for belongings or particular items, so check each section. Our declarations page guide shows how to trace each section. Read each section’s basis rather than assuming one rule governs the whole policy.

Questions to ask before you need to claim

Ask your insurer or a licensed agent, and keep the answers in writing:

Know what is excluded entirely

A settlement basis only matters for a covered loss. NAIC says flood and earthquake are typically excluded from homeowners and renters policies. FEMA says most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, and that flood insurance is a separate policy that can cover buildings, contents or both. FEMA also notes a typical 30-day waiting period for a National Flood Insurance Program policy to take effect, with some exceptions (FEMA, checked November 18, 2026). The FEMA page read for this guide does not discuss replacement cost or ACV for flood policies, so ask about the basis on any flood or earthquake policy separately.

Keep records that support the valuation

Whichever basis applies, you generally have to show what you owned. A home inventory with photos, receipts and model numbers makes a claim easier to document. Our guide to homeowners and renters policies explains how to organize the documents. Comparing prices across insurers, and how a higher deductible changes premiums, is a Money Master topic: start at Money Master, or see its insurance basics guide for the vocabulary.

A closed jewelry-style wooden box and a vase on a shelf.

Common questions

Is replacement cost always better? It pays more on a given loss, but policies are priced and worded differently. Compare actual terms, including the cost and limits.

Does ACV mean the insurer pays what I paid originally? No. NAIC describes it as the cost to repair or replace after depreciation.

Does homeowners insurance cover flood? NAIC says typically not; FEMA says most homeowners insurance does not. Flood insurance is a separate policy.

Where do I find my settlement basis? In the policy’s loss-settlement wording and endorsements. If the wording is unclear, ask the insurer to explain it in writing.

Sources checked November 18, 2026: NAIC guide to understanding homeowners and renters policies; FEMA flood insurance page.